Castrol

Castrol GTX Ultra Clean 10W-40 A/B

Technical Conclusion:
All parameters are good.
LiquiMoly

LiquiMoly TOP TEC 4600 5W-30

Technical Conclusion:
The phosphorus content of the oil is measured at 0.068%, which is below the specified range of 0.07%–0.09% required for ACEA C2, C3, MB 229.51, BMW LL-04, VW 50500/50501 and GM Dexos 2 specifications. Phosphorus is essential for engine protection as it serves as an anti-wear additive. Insufficient phosphorus may lead to accelerated engine wear and reduced durability, especially under high-stress conditions. This discrepancy suggests that the oil may not fully meet the necessary requirements for optimal engine protection and longevity as outlined by these specifications.
COMMA X-Flow

COMMA X-Flow ACEA A3/B4

Technical Conclusion:
The conclusion is that the oil meets all the required specifications. This includes the API, ACEA, and other related performance standards, and the test result is PASS.
FEBI BLISTIEN

FEBI BLISTIEN 75W-90 GL-5

Technical Conclusion:
In summary, FEBI BILSTEIN 75W-90 GL-5 may not meet the necessary performance standards for high-load and cold-temperature applications expected of API GL-5 gear oils. The low weld load, noted at 315 kg, falls below the typical minimum of 350 kg for API GL-5 oils, indicating insufficient load-carrying capacity. This shortfall suggests that the oil may be less effective under high-pressure conditions, leading to increased wear and reduced component durability. Given these deficiencies, it is likely that this oil is more similar in performance to a GL-4 grade oil, making it potentially unsuitable for the demanding conditions commonly found in gear systems that require full GL-5 protection.

Other Threads

CARLUBE CVT-U Fluid Driveline

CARLUBE

Castrol Magnatec 0W-30 ACEA C2

Castrol

COMMA Ecoren

COMMA

CVT FEBI BLISTIEN

FEBI BLISTIEN

TOTAL INEO LONGLIFE 5W-30 C3 API SN/CF

TOTAL

COMMA X-Flow ACEA A5/B5

COMMA X-Flow

Mobil Super3000

MOBIL

TRANSELF NFX SAE 75W GL-4

ELF

ZF LIFEGUARD FLUID 9 ATF D-II

ZF

Shell HELIX ULTRA 5W-20 WSS-M2C948-BCASE

Shell

Shell HELIX ULTRA 5W-30 ECT C3 MB229.51/31

Shell

CARLUBE DRIVELINE ATF LV

CARLUBE